Ad
cheetah127 November 18, 2008

Why do schools now want all children to lose their creative expressions?

cheetah127
Yesterday was conference day. There is a new section on the report card called Visual and Performing Arts Achievement and I was told that because my 2nd grader was still drawing stick figures that she is Below Basic. I argued that that is just how she draws and they told me that they have to learn depth that people are not sticks.I think this is absurd! I want my child to continue to draw and express herself as she has always done. Why do we want all children to be the same? I am not going to stand by and let the school system tell my child how to draw, that is ridiculous! Picasso didn't exactly "follow the rules" either you know. Every child expresses themselves in different ways and I think it is horrible that we are trying to create a future generation of nonthinkers, we are making all kids have the same mindset, and that is going to destroy the arts forever. Is anyone else concerned about this at all?
Answer this question

Parent Answers to "Why do schools now want all children to lose their creative expressions?"

RSS View 11 answers: Newest-Oldest, Oldest-Newest
Display all answers
Child_Of_Ra
Child_Of_Ra January 11, 2009
Art is much like beauty as that it's in the eye of the beholder.

I am an artist and have been in classes of different levels, and seen schools graded differently, even now with my kids. However, the most common thought now, with kids especially, is that art is not graded by the same rules as the other subjects. While it's also not a recess with a crayon type of class, it's meant nowadays to stimulate the child's creative processes.

My daughter didn't draw anything *but* stick figures until 3rd grade, when she finally began drawing simple landscapes, and now with an easy and short book about learning how to draw that I purchased her at the art store, she's been drawing very well. She's 11 now and has been drawing well for a couple of years.

I'd bet your daughter will come around in her own time frame.
queensmom
queensmom January 11, 2009
its also a fact that left handed people are smarter!!! and most of our U.S.PRESIDENTS where left handed. as well as most of the billionaires in the world!!! that is a fact that you can research also!!! hang in there i have a daughter also, and she is very expressive and VERY CREATIVE!!!
Johnston
Johnston January 1, 2009
My daughters are creative in different ways. My older daughter can draw like her dad..pretty much anything she tries, but when she tries to sing, she can't carry much of a tune. My younger daughter works very hard to draw even a fraction of how her sister draws, but she's lucky to get much more than stick figures. She can sing most anything though.

I've always encouraged them to express themselves in any healthy way possible. The fact that my older daughter almost makes me cringe when she tries to hit a high note (not done on the outside of course..lol), doesn't stop her and I wouldn't want it too. They both love to do what they do and I wouldn't have it any other way.

I wouldn't worry about this evaluation. Just continue to encourage your daughter to express herself. Remember, back in our parents day, they thought left handed people were retarded (a fact I found out from my grandmother). Both of my parents were left handed, as are my husband and I. Everyone is different, and it should be celebrated, not condemned.
Anonymous
Anonymous December 16, 2008
I am a college art instructor and artist and I must respond to your comment about Picasso. He was a trained artist who at 16 could paint an academic portrait as realistic as any you've seen. Few people outside of art realize this because they don't bother to dig deeper, just reiterate the same old stereotype. Picasso was a genius who was very much a part of the artistic upheavals of the late 19th century. Yes, the Impressionists broke with tradition, buy they were also from that tradition....Degas was a remarkable draftsman, Van Gogh copied Millet....there's an old saying in art that you learn the rules so you can break them. As someone who taught children art for many years, many children will regard art as more than play time, or "fun" if they are shown that there is more to it than just "expressing one's self. I once taught perspective and spatial drawing to a group of 9 to 12 year olds and they loved it! It opened up there eyes about how to create a sense of space and distance. All of the Disney classics were created by animators who were VERY skilled artists and draftsmen. It is far past the time for us to start treating visual art as more than just the fun class in elementary school and imparting a healthy respect and admiration for what artists do. As the great Graphic Artist Milton Glaser (creator of I heart NY), once said....."art is work". And yes, it's fun too.....sometimes.
nljabb
nljabb November 25, 2008
I don't think this developmental evaluation had anything to do with suppressing your child's expression. I don't think you should ignore this evaluation either. Rather, as a caring/concerned parent reasses this area of your child's development. I agree with you that there is nothing wrong with drawing stick figures. They are cute, simple, and they get to the point, but I think that when you repeatedly see this same pattern of drawing from a developing child, you have to wonder if perhaps they don't notice the details (a developmental delay). As her mom have you noticed your child ever draw figures that are more detailed than stick figures? Take what you know about your child's abillity to identify detailed human body parts (e.g. nails, eyebrows, nostrils, etc.) and ask your child's teacher if all of the human depictions in her work are always "stick figures'? Should it be a developmental delay, don't lose sleep over it, just be aware and whenever possible discuss details in her human drawings. Make a game of it, this might help bring about awareness and thus develope this area. Most importantly, keep in mind that not all kids develope in all areas at the same rate. I'm sure she'll do fine...I know because my child got a similar evaluation about eight years ago and today he's doing fine notices all of the details and then some... : )
1 2 3 Next >

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of GreatSchools. GreatSchools does not check for accuracy in community posts or verify the contributor’s identity. If you are searching for health-related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Community Guidelines for more details.

Local Q&A

Top cities

Browse questions about

Local Q&A is brand new! What do you think? Give us your feedback in our feedback forum.
AD

AD
Join the community or login
Join the community or
Read our community guidelines and FAQ
Community Moderator
Email the Community Moderator for help
tracker