Ad
Anonymous December 12, 2007

My first-grader can't get along with his teacher, and she wants to have him tested for ADHD. What should I do?

Anonymous
My son is in first grade. He did not have any major behavior problems last year. Since we and other people — as well as last year's teacher — haven't had behavior problems with him, we really don't think it is ADHD. His current teacher would like us to get him tested. But she is the only one who seems to have a problem with him; everyone is shocked at his apparent disrespect for her. And as far as she can see, he's a perfect ADHD candidate. He certainly does act that way with her. How do I find out why they are at each others throats? There has to be something between their personalities that causes this clash.
Answer this question

Answer From Our Expert

GreatSchools Staff DebraCollins December 12, 2007
Your son's "disrespectful" behavior is not, in and of itself, reason to suspect ADHD. Impulsivity, non-compliance and social inappropriateness are just some of the behaviors attributed to ADHD.

The American Psychiatric Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics are excellent resources to help familiarize you with the diagnostic criteria for ADHD, as well as other childhood disorders. Mood disorders, such as depression and anxiety, can lead to "acting out" behavior, as well as undiagnosed learning disabilities. Knowing more about these issues can help you decide when to consider having your child tested.

Changes in family life can also cause acting out in school. Examine if there have been any recent developments in the family or the family routine that might be cause for anxiety. Remember, what may not be upsetting to you may be to your son.

Try some investigative reporting with your child. Be careful not to blame either the teacher or your child. Try something like, "Gee, you had such a good time in kindergarten, I wonder what's different about first grade." Give your child an opportunity to express what is difficult about his experience so that you can strategize some solutions.

Make sure you are clear on what behavioral expectations the teacher has of your child and that your child is clear about them as well. Be specific and break the classroom rules down into manageable steps.

Over the course of your child's life he will need to learn how to deal with people he may not care for. One thing you can do at home is avoid "venting" about people in authority, like a boss, spouse, etc. It is best to model "working it out" rather than "acting out."
DebraCollins
Advice from our experts is not a substitute for medical or other professional advice and services from a qualified health-care provider familiar with your unique situation. We recommend consulting a qualified professional if you have concerns about your child's medical or emotional condition.

Parent Answers to "My first-grader can't get along with his teacher, and she wants to have him tested for ADHD. What should I do?"

RSS View 7 answers: Newest-Oldest, Oldest-Newest
Display fewer answers
Rodgers
Rodgers April 9, 2009
Remember that the school system is a team, they will cover each others backs. How you like your 11th grader, son or daughter coming home sharing that the Algebra teacher advises that "you should just drop out."
Momm_of_two2
Momm_of_two2 March 8, 2009
I am hoping you can update me on this and tell me what happened. My son is in 1st grade now too and he has a 1st time teacher. He done great in kindergarten. The whole year he has been getting in trouble and shes nothing like our last teacher. She says he might be adhd.
Rodgers
Rodgers January 29, 2009
Dont be surprized if the teacher is abusing your child in some way. This is common practice that will lead to more issues as your child grows.
JBPsych
JBPsych January 5, 2009
Getting a private psychological or educational evaluation misses the problem which is IN THE SChool.
Private evaluators do not know or bother to find out the school climate, teacher expectations, or do direct observations. Clinical evaluations do not enlist the principal and support staff to assist in the evaluation.
The answers which involved a break down the behavioral expectations, get a functional behavioral assessment, and to have to parent review information about learning problems and possible ADHD are better starting points.
parentadvocate
parentadvocate February 18, 2008
Sounds to me more like a possible learning diasbility. Most children with a disability become very frustrated and act out as a way of saying " Hey I have issues here" I would ask your school district for a behavioral specialist to come in and look at the behaviors, also would ask for a psychological exam be done. I would also consider going to a psuchologist that deals with childs learning diabilities such as a Ph.d and getting a second opinion, for the sake of a possible LD and other medical problems.
Good luck!
chriscnaz
chriscnaz February 2, 2008
Start with educating yourself and most likely having to educate the teacher as well. For ADHD to be considered the symptoms would need to occur in more than one setting ( her classroom). www.aacap.org/cs/adhd_a_guide_for_families/what_is_adhd

If this behavior is an ongoing concern for you or the teacher request a functional behavior assessment which is designed to determine the enviromental things that occur before, during and after a behavior allowing you to help predict why it might be occuring and what can be done instead. This assessment is then used to develop a positive behavior support plan which is directed at those working with him to allow for a change to more positive behaviors.

All too many times ADHD becomes a catch all or an easy target and way to blame the child when interactions are always 2 sided and not always the child's "fault". Always request an objective nuetral observer to help get to the root of the problem, rather than letting your child accept blame which may not be theirs.
AdvocateMom
AdvocateMom January 24, 2008
Get a private educational comprehensive psych. evaluation. If you have private insurance see if the will pay for it before signing any permission forms. It is better to never allow the school to test or give them permission if you can help it. If you must and then disagree with thier results then ask for an independent eval "at public expense".

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of GreatSchools. GreatSchools does not check for accuracy in community posts or verify the contributor’s identity. If you are searching for health-related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Community Guidelines for more details.
Local Q&A is brand new! What do you think? Give us your feedback in our feedback forum.
AD
Join the community or login
Join the community or
Read our community guidelines and FAQ
Community Moderator
Email the Community Moderator for help
tracker