Ad

 

  • Private school teachers are less qualified, less educated and less experienced than public school teachers. They are often parents who have lost their day job, or nursery school teachers promoted beyond their experience.
  • Private school standardized test scores (ERB) are not published. What are they hiding?
  • Studies show private school students are much more likely to drop out of college than public school students.
  • Private school class size is often larger than public school class size. Often classes are larger than the CA public school 20 student per class K-3 cap, especially in religious schools. Public schools have many more volunteers, including student teachers, in the classroom, reducing the published teacher/student ratio. 
  • Private schools have little sense of community. They tend to be drive-and-drop schools, not neighborhood schools.
  • Private schools can close at will without public hearings.
  • Private schools are often so far in debt their main focus is fund raising, not education.
  • Private schools are racially homogenous, promoting ignorance about and prejudice toward other races
  • Bullying is more of a problem in private than in public schools. Public schools have zero tolerance for bullying. Bullying by children whose parents contribute financially to the school is often tolerated in private schools.
  • Private school problems are hidden from the general public as well as from families in the schools, unlike public school problems, which are always widely reported.
  • Local newspapers accept advertising dollars from private schools, leading to a lack of journalistic integrity in school reporting.
Add a comment

Parent Comments on "Hidden problems of private schools"

RSS View 44 comments: Newest-Oldest, Oldest-Newest
Display all comments
stretchaustin
stretchaustin May 6, 2009
Re: Hidden problems of private schools
Not all public school are the same either- but my experience with this particular private school is not a good experience- and since I have no other frame of reference- that is my opinion on private schools. But I am sure that some private schools are really great. I agree that research should be done on whatever school- public or private.
rhaspc
rhaspc May 6, 2009
Re: Hidden problems of private schools
Hmmm, icould it be that maybe you have a problem with the particular school your child is in? For any school, I think it is importance to do research and make sure you are comfortable with your cildren in that particular school....but to make such a blanket statement...well, it is just ridiculous!! I went to a private school, and when tested in public school system...I tested out for 3 grade levels higher than the public school system...Not all private schools are the same....it doesn't matter how much you are or are not paying for the education; I have learned that it is important to do some research for yourself!!
stretchaustin
stretchaustin May 5, 2009
Re: Hidden problems of private schools
I agree with this post. I have two kids in California public schools and 1 child in a private religious school in Texas. My kids in public school are being taught higher quality curriculum than the child in private school. Our public school principal has his PhD- our teachers all have degrees- their are alot of parent volunteers and other resources available (reading, math, speech specialists)-- My child at the private school in Texas - well his teacher has no teaching credentials- she has poor grammar herself - is not familiar with the Internet-- does not communicate with me very well- and I feel like he is not getting a quality education. The school is not accredited-- I am wondering if their is a way to report bad private schools- any suggestions? Or is it that private schools can just do whatever they want and teacher whatever they want?
upwardmom
upwardmom May 5, 2009
Re: Hidden problems of private schools
Wow. Definately a glass half empty view. I guess I was expecting some balanced information. Like other families in a non denominational private Christian school may not have be operating from a Biblical World view, though they are professing Christians. Little of those comments are accurate from my experiences.
sunnynwarmer
sunnynwarmer May 5, 2009
Re: Hidden problems of private schools

My child has been in private school since kindergarten and I've seen some of the issues listed, especially the "favoritism".
Overall though, I see more parents involved in their child's education, more of a sense of community and the students seem to display more respect to the teachers, school property and to other’s in general.
This is not saying the private school kids, parents, and teachers are perfect; not at all. A lot depends on the administration of the school and how curriculum and policies are decided.

Private schools can give a more personalized attention to a student, for example:
1) If the school is aware of a student's financial, familial or personal hardship, the school will get involved to help that student and their family.

2) If a student is continually displaying actions outside of their normal behavior, they are counseled and helped.

3) Parents are informed immediately if the student is missing an assignment, project or is absent from class. Many schools provide the academic average for each class via a private login session and are updated daily.

Conversely:
1) A student can be easily labeled after only one incident or very high expectations can be placed on legacy students (e.g.: "Your brother/sister/mom/dad was my best/worst student. Should I expect the same from you?")

2) Those with high academic standings are expected to consistently perform well, regardless of the subject.

3) The extra-curricular programs are funded by parents and by fundraising activities, which your child may be required to do.
Most activities require purchasing the school logo warm-up clothing, mandated shoes and equipment. Costs for these add up very quickly.
Some activities require parents to provide travel to and from “away” games.

Choosing to send your child to a public or a private school is a decision based on many factors, including the child's overall personality and academic abilities. Most private schools do not offer robust remedial or any special education classes.
You will pay a tuition that will probably increase each year; though many private schools help needy families to meet the financial obligations and some schools offer full scholarships.

Again, there are many positives and negatives in choosing a private school over the public school. Compare the schools, meet with the administrators, attend a PTA meeting. That way, you may also speak with parents of children attending the school and maybe get a better perspective.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Next >

Related keywords: bullying, problems, privateschool, independentschool

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of GreatSchools. GreatSchools does not check for accuracy in community posts or verify the contributor’s identity. If you are searching for health-related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Community Guidelines for more details.

Local Q&A

Top cities

Browse questions about

Local Q&A is brand new! What do you think? Give us your feedback in our feedback forum.
AD

AD
Join the community or login
Join the community or
Read our community guidelines and FAQ
Community Moderator
Email the Community Moderator for help
tracker